مقالات الرأي

From the Crisis to the Core ( CC)  Title:  The Solution to the Government’s Failure to Run the State (From Silent Withdrawal to Active Participation)

Date: November 19, 2026

When a government fails to provide basic services and protect its citizens, many assume there are only two options: ( either / or ) wait or explode.

– Wait for a reform that may never come,

– or unleash a popular rage that tears everything down.

–

–

–

Reality, however, is richer and more complex than this binary.

Between silence and revolution lies a wide space where real politics is made every day, by people who hold no power or office but who possess something more important:

– The capacity for collective action

(Withdrawal Is Not Weakness)

In his book Escape from Domination in Africa, Bruce Baker offers a different reading of how the poor deal with unaccountable authorities (philosophically, scientifically, religiously and artistically).

Rather than confronting a state that outmatches them in arms and equipment, they resort to what he calls “political withdrawal”:

They avoid institutions that do not serve them,

and build local alternatives to what the state has failed to provide.

According to the book, this withdrawal is not surrender or passivity, but an effective and calculated response to governments’ failure to provide services and protection.

Yet, for all its cleverness, this withdrawal remains in the end a symptom of illness, not a cure.

A society that learns to live apart from its state may survive, but the state is left hollow, and the gap between it and its citizens widens day by day.

Hence the question:

– How do we turn this withdrawn energy into a force for building?

Everyday Politics, Where Decisions Are Actually Made :

The concept of “everyday politics” answers this question.

It holds that ordinary people’s influence on public affairs is not limited to the ballot box, but extends to their daily conduct and practices.

Community cooperation,

neighbors organizing themselves to solve a shared problem,

and even forms of silent resistance

are all simple acts that carry real political weight in steering decisions and changing reality.

Harry Boyte, in his book Everyday Politics (2004), went further.

He criticized the traditional view that confines politics to party competition and the distribution of power among elites.

He argued that real politics is citizens working together to solve their common problems and build their communities, away from ideological polarization, so that the citizen becomes an active partner and producer, not merely a consumer of services or a spectator of events.

The two approaches meet at one truth:

– Politics is not made only in parliaments and palaces of power; ordinary people practice it daily, through clever and quiet ways of dealing with authority.

The difference between them is one of direction:

– Withdrawal moves away from the state,

while everyday politics rebuilds reality from the bottom up.

The solution lies in combining the two: the initiatives of people who have withdrawn from the state should become a partnership with it once it is ready to listen, through the following elements of a solution:

First: Acknowledge that failure is what pushed people to withdraw.

When citizens withdraw, that is a message worth reading, not accusing.

The first step toward reform is for the government to ask itself:

– What drove people out of my circle?

Second: Build on local initiatives instead of competing with them.

Communities that built their own schools, wells and protection committees have proven their ability to manage.

A smart state supports these initiatives, granting them recognition and resources, thereby moving from the position of controller to that of partner.

Third: Broaden the meaning of participation. Citizenship should not be reduced to voting once every few years. Permanent channels for consultation and community oversight of services should be opened, so that citizens feel their voice changes something in their daily lives.

Fourth: Restore trust through genuine accountability.

Citizens will not return to a state that neglects them and does not hold the negligent to account.

Without transparency and accountability, withdrawal will remain the wiser choice.

Conclusion

The government’s failure to run the state is not the end of the road, so long as society holds energies working quietly.

The solution comes neither from a lone savior nor from a revolution that demolishes what remains, but from restoring the standing of politics as shared daily work. When

the state learns to listen,

and the citizen learns to participate,

withdrawal turns into return, and politics turns from an arena of elites into a project built by everyone.

زر الذهاب إلى الأعلى